Journal article · 2024 · Open access

Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools

Tim Woelfle, Julian Hirt, Perrine Janiaud, Ludwig Kappos, John P. A. Ioannidis, Lars G. Hemkens

Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 175, 111533 · Published 12 September 2024 · DOI 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533

Open PDFView at the publisherCite this paper

In brief

“Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools” is a 2024 journal article by Tim Woelfle and 5 co-authors, published in Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. OpenAlex counts 59 citations as of 18 November 2026. It is open access under a CC BY licence: the full text is free to read at Journal of Clinical Epidemiology.

Citations
59
Most cited in
2026 (33)
Field-weighted impact
5.55
References
44
Authors
6

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: It is unknown whether large language models (LLMs) may facilitate time- and resource-intensive text-related processes in evidence appraisal. The objective was to quantify the agreement of LLMs with human consensus in appraisal of scientific reporting (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses [PRISMA]) and methodological rigor (A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews [AMSTAR]) of systematic reviews and design of clinical trials (PRagmatic Explanatory Continuum Indicator Summary 2 [PRECIS-2]) and to identify areas where collaboration between humans and artificial intelligence (AI) would outperform the traditional consensus process of human raters in efficiency. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Five LLMs (Claude-3-Opus, Claude-2, GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Mixtral-8x22B) assessed 112 systematic reviews applying the PRISMA and AMSTAR criteria and 56 randomized controlled trials applying PRECIS-2. We quantified the agreement between human consensus and (1) individual human raters; (2) individual LLMs; (3) combined LLMs approach; (4) human-AI collaboration. Ratings were marked as deferred (undecided) in case of inconsistency between combined LLMs or between the human rater and the LLM. RESULTS: Individual human rater accuracy was 89% for PRISMA and AMSTAR, and 75% for PRECIS-2. Individual LLM accuracy was ranging from 63% (GPT-3.5) to 70% (Claude-3-Opus) for PRISMA, 53% (GPT-3.5) to 74% (Claude-3-Opus) for AMSTAR, and 38% (GPT-4) to 55% (GPT-3.5) for PRECIS-2. Combined LLM ratings led to accuracies of 75%-88% for PRISMA (4%-74% deferred), 74%-89% for AMSTAR (6%-84% deferred), and 64%-79% for PRECIS-2 (29%-88% deferred). Human-AI collaboration resulted in the best accuracies from 89% to 96% for PRISMA (25/35% deferred), 91%-95% for AMSTAR (27/30% deferred), and 80%-86% for PRECIS-2 (76/71% deferred). CONCLUSION: Current LLMs alone appraised evidence worse than humans. Human-AI collaboration may reduce workload for the second human rater for the assessment of reporting (PRISMA) and methodological rigor (AMSTAR) but not for complex tasks such as PRECIS-2.

Cite this paper

Formatted from the catalogue record. Check names, capitals and page numbers against the paper before you submit.

APA 7

Woelfle, T., Hirt, J., Janiaud, P., Kappos, L., Ioannidis, J. P. A., & Hemkens, L. G. (2024). Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 175, 111533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533

MLA 9

Woelfle, Tim, et al. “Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, vol. 175, 2024, p. 111533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533.

Chicago

Woelfle, Tim, Julian Hirt, Perrine Janiaud, Ludwig Kappos, John P. A. Ioannidis, and Lars G. Hemkens. 2024. “Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 175: 111533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533.

Harvard

Woelfle, T. et al. (2024) ‘Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools’, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 175, p. 111533. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533.

IEEE

T. Woelfle, J. Hirt, P. Janiaud, L. Kappos, J. P. A. Ioannidis, and L. G. Hemkens, “Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, vol. 175, p. 111533, 2024, doi: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533.

BibTeX

@article{woelfle2024benchmarking,
  title     = {{Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools}},
  author    = {Woelfle, Tim and Hirt, Julian and Janiaud, Perrine and Kappos, Ludwig and Ioannidis, John P. A. and Hemkens, Lars G.},
  journal   = {Journal of Clinical Epidemiology},
  year      = {2024},
  volume    = {175},
  pages     = {111533},
  doi       = {10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533},
  url       = {https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533}
}

Download for a reference manager: BibTeX (.bib) · RIS for Zotero, Mendeley and EndNote (.ris)

Citations by year

YearCitationsShare of the best year
202422
20252424
20263333

Its field-weighted citation impact is 5.55: it has been cited 5.55 times as often as the average work of the same field, type and year (1.00 is the world average).

Topic and keywords

Social Sciences › Decision Sciences › Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty › Meta-analysis and systematic reviews

  • large language models
  • human-AI collaboration
  • evidence appraisal
  • PRISMA
  • AMSTAR
  • PRECIS-2
  • systematic reviews
  • randomized controlled trials

Work with this paper

Most-cited papers in Decision Sciences

All highly cited Decision Sciences papers

Questions about this paper

How do I cite this paper in APA style?

Woelfle, T., Hirt, J., Janiaud, P., Kappos, L., Ioannidis, J. P. A., & Hemkens, L. G. (2024). Benchmarking Human–AI collaboration for common evidence appraisal tools. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 175, 111533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533

How many times has this paper been cited?

59 times, according to OpenAlex on 18 November 2026. Google Scholar and Scopus count different sets of sources, so their numbers differ.

Is this paper free to read?

Yes. It is open access at Journal of Clinical Epidemiology: sign in and open the PDF from this page.

Who wrote this paper?

Tim Woelfle, Julian Hirt, Perrine Janiaud, Ludwig Kappos, John P. A. Ioannidis, Lars G. Hemkens.

What is the DOI of this paper?

10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533, permanently at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111533. Sign in and open it from this page.

Bibliographic data from OpenAlex (CC0), last checked 18 November 2026. ResearchGuru does not host this paper; once you are signed in, the links open it at the publisher or the repository that does.